Democrats Can't Beat the Electoral College, So They're Trying to Kill It

New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill signed her state onto the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact this month with a complaint dressed up as a principle: "Our votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is. That's not democracy." Wyoming, for the record, has three electoral votes. New Jersey has fourteen.

Sherrill's math doesn't add up. Her argument doesn't need to.

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is a scheme that's been lurking in state legislatures for years, and the November 2026 blue wave just handed it new life. As Just The News reported, 18 states plus the District of Columbia have already signed on, pledging to award their electoral votes not to the candidate their own residents chose, but to whoever wins the national popular vote. The compact kicks in once participating states hit 270 electoral votes — the same number needed to win the presidency. Five states that flipped Democratic in November — Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin — could push the compact past the finish line without a single constitutional amendment, a single congressional vote, or a single say from the other 27 states.

That's the design. Not a bug.

The Constitution is specific about this. Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 gives state legislatures the authority to determine how electors are appointed. Compact supporters have leaned on that language for years, arguing that if a state legislature wants to hand its electoral votes to the national popular vote winner, it's free to do so. What they'd prefer you not read is Article I, Section 10, Clause 3, which requires congressional consent for interstate compacts that affect the balance of political power. Attorney General Todd Blanche put it plainly: "It shouldn't get past the district court... we will take it to the Supreme Court if we have to."

The legal fight is coming. The political motive behind it isn't even debatable.

Donald Trump won the popular vote and the Electoral College in 2024. Before that, the last two times a president won the White House while losing the popular vote — George W. Bush in 2000 and Trump himself in 2016 — Democrats treated it as a constitutional crisis. The compact movement started gaining traction after 2000 and accelerated hard after 2016. Prior to the 21st century, a popular-vote-Electoral-College split had happened exactly three times: 1824, 1876, and 1888. Two bad outcomes in sixteen years, and Democrats decided the whole system needed to go.

Governor-elect David Crowley in Wisconsin and Governor Josh Shapiro in Pennsylvania now sit in the exact positions needed to deliver their states to the compact. Michigan, Arizona, and Nevada all shifted left in November. The infrastructure is there. The governors are willing. Inez Stepman, Senior Policy and Legal Analyst at the Independent Women's Forum, warned in a piece for National Review that "it seems like the right has barely realized the importance of the fight that's about to begin."

She's not wrong. The compact doesn't require a two-thirds vote in Congress. It doesn't require ratification by three-fourths of state legislatures. It doesn't require any of the safeguards the Founders built into the amendment process for exactly this kind of structural change. It routes around all of them. Five governors with friendly legislatures could effectively rewrite how America picks its president, and the 27 states that didn't sign on would have zero recourse until a court stepped in.

The Supreme Court has already signaled interest in the edges of this question. In Chiafolo v. Washington, the Court upheld state authority over how electors vote. In Miller v. Washington in 2019, a voter standing challenge to the compact was dismissed — not on the merits, but on standing. Neither case answered the central constitutional question: can a bloc of states contractually override the Electoral College without Congress signing off?

That question now has a deadline. Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin have the combined electoral votes to put the compact over 270. New governors take office in January. Legislative sessions start shortly after.

The Founders didn't build the Electoral College because they forgot about math. They built it because a country that stretches from Maine to Missouri to Mississippi needs a system where Wyoming's three votes actually matter — where a candidate has to win a coalition of states, not just run up the score in California and New York. The compact doesn't eliminate the Electoral College on paper. It just makes it a rubber stamp for the popular vote, which is the same thing with extra steps.

Five state legislatures. Five governors' signatures. No constitutional amendment. That's the margin between the system the Founders designed and the one Democrats couldn't get through Congress.


Most Popular

Most Popular